The only pitch I saw on that run-through of SportsCenter was the called strike three on Hanley Ramirez, which Hanley thought was low and/or inside and I thought was a strike.
So an hour later the highlights run by again and this time I take a closer look. Looked like Mike DiMuro* had a fairly wide strike zone, but I didn't think any of the calls were outrageous. I said things like, "you can't take that pitch with two strikes" and "I don't have a problem with that call."
Then my friend called me a homer and started goofing on me.
*Just note, I am always wary of second-generation officials, like the batshit Crawford brothers in the NBA; Mike's father Lou was an American League umpire from the '60s into the '80s. I'll sometimes go out of my way to criticize guys like DiMuro and Hunter Wendelstedt, but didn't see fit this time.
I went home later and read a bunch of stuff about the game, including Joe Posnanski's account of it, and I didn't find any complaints of bias in ball-and-strike calls, including from Marlins players and coaches. Just a couple allusions to a relatively big strike zone.
How big, though? I went to Matty's go-to site for umpire watchdoggery, Brooks Baseball, to find out. Here is Halladay's ball-and-strike plot (click to approximately double its size):
*I am wildly colorblind and, in fact, there could be upwards of 25 such pitches on the plot. I just can't find them.
Just had my wife look at the plot: six called strikes slightly outside the box (one about 4 inches outside*; that's the furthest outside of any called strike), all in the same general location, and two called balls inside the box, both in the same general location.
*Four inches in reality, not on the graph, dummy.
You know what that's called: a pretty good, consistent strike zone. At least two of the outside called strikes were early in the game (saw them on TV), which should tell the hitters that the pitcher is getting calls on the outside corner, and they should adapt accordingly.
For comparison, Josh Johnson's plot for this game is below. It's harder to interpret for balls and strikes because the Phillies put a lot more balls in play than the Marlins did (despite scoring only 1 run, unearned at that), and even my wife can't tell the difference between the green used for Called Strikes and the green used for Missed Bunts on my computer screen.
Looks like DiMuro squeezed Johnson (heh heh heh m heh) on the inside corner a bit, but there's a called strike on this plot that's twice as far outside the strike zone as any he conceded to Halladay.Especially in light of some of the wretched home-plate umpiring Matty has monitored on this site in the past, last night's perfect game was officiated rather well.
Furthermore, if bloated windbags like Cowpie Joe West would start calling the strike zone a little wider -- and do it consistently -- a 9-inning Yankees/Red Sox game might not last four and a half hours.
So, to sum up: I am not a homer*; I think my friend was just hatin'.
*Then why did I do all this?
.
























